Product Reviews

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray Review: A Two-Piece Oven Air Fryer Set

A practical fit for cooks who want to crisp, bake, roast, or reheat smaller portions in a regular or convection oven.

This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you.

For shoppers searching gotham steel air fryer reviews, this Gotham Steel Crisper Tray is an oven accessory rather than a standalone appliance: its raised mesh basket sits over a solid pan for air circulation and drippings.

The two-piece, 13.12-inch round set is aimed at cooks who want to use an oven’s air-fry or convection setting without adding a countertop fryer.

Gotham Steel Crisper Review Summary

The quick verdict

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray
4.5/5

13,000+ ratings

Read Amazon Reviews

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

A practical fit for cooks who want to crisp, bake, roast, or reheat smaller portions in a regular or convection oven.

  • Two-piece set with an elevated mesh basket and solid drip pan.
  • Round, copper-colored set measuring 13.12 inches across.
  • Aluminum core with Gotham Steel titanium and ceramic nonstick coating.
  • Designed for oven air-fry, convection, bake, roast, and reheat settings.

Pros

  • Combines a raised basket and drip pan in one coordinated set.
  • Can support several oven cooking methods beyond air frying.

Consider before buying

  • Its round 13.12-inch footprint needs to be checked against the oven rack and available clearance.
  • The description provides no capacity guidance, so batch size may take some trial and planning.
Read the full review summary

The central idea is straightforward: food rests in an elevated mesh basket while the pan underneath catches grease and crumbs.

The open basket is designed to let hot air circulate around food, and the set can also be used for baking, roasting, and reheating.

Its copper-colored titanium and ceramic nonstick coating, aluminum core, and dishwasher-safe construction make it appealing to someone who prefers oven cooking and wants a dedicated crisping surface.

This is most suitable for modest batches and kitchens with an oven or convection oven that can accommodate a round tray of this size.

It does not replace a standalone air fryer, and the description does not establish that it fits every oven or produces a particular degree of crispness.

Measure the usable rack area and check your oven’s guidance for accessories before buying.

The buying factors

Gotham Steel Crisper Scorecard

Editorial scores reflect listed features and buyer fit; they are not laboratory measurements or customer ratings.

8/10

Oven versatility

The set is described for air-fry, bake, roast, and reheat use, giving it several roles in an oven.

8/10

Airflow-oriented design

The raised mesh basket leaves space beneath and around food for hot-air circulation.

8/10

Mess management

A solid pan beneath the basket is intended to catch grease and crumbs.

7/10

Cleanup convenience

The nonstick coating and dishwasher-safe construction are useful conveniences; care instructions should still be checked for the buyer’s preferred routine.

6/10

Capacity flexibility

The 13.12-inch round format may suit smaller oven loads, but the description gives no usable food capacity.

7/10

Material and coating details

The listed aluminum core and titanium and ceramic nonstick coating offer useful detail, though buyers should follow the product’s care guidance.

Key Features and Specifications of Gotham Steel Crisper

  • Two-piece set with an elevated mesh basket and solid drip pan.
  • Round, copper-colored set measuring 13.12 inches across.
  • Aluminum core with Gotham Steel titanium and ceramic nonstick coating.
  • Designed for oven air-fry, convection, bake, roast, and reheat settings.
  • Dishwasher-safe construction, with a nonstick surface intended to ease food release.
  • The pan beneath the basket is designed to catch grease and crumbs.

Pros and Cons of Gotham Steel Crisper

Pros

  • Combines a raised basket and drip pan in one coordinated set.
  • Can support several oven cooking methods beyond air frying.
  • The under-basket pan helps contain drips and loose crumbs.
  • Nonstick coating and dishwasher-safe construction may simplify routine cleanup.

Consider before buying

  • Its round 13.12-inch footprint needs to be checked against the oven rack and available clearance.
  • The description provides no capacity guidance, so batch size may take some trial and planning.
  • It relies on an oven or convection oven; it is not a standalone air fryer.

Who Should Buy Gotham Steel Crisper?

Good fit

Consider the Gotham Steel Crisper if you already use an oven’s air-fry or convection setting and want a raised mesh surface with a pan underneath.

The two-piece design gives you a place for food and a catch surface for grease and crumbs, which can make oven crisping less messy than placing food directly on a flat pan.

It may also suit cooks who want one accessory for air-fry, bake, roast, and reheat tasks.

Before ordering, compare the 13.12-inch round size with your rack dimensions and think about how much food you usually prepare at once; the provided description does not specify capacity.

Who should skip it

Skip this set if your main need is a self-contained countertop air fryer. It is designed to be used inside an oven, so its usefulness depends on having a suitable oven and enough room for the round tray.

Look elsewhere if you need a clearly specified large-batch capacity or a tray shape tailored to a particular rack layout. Check your oven’s accessory guidance and measure the cooking area before deciding.

How the Gotham Steel Crisper Fits Oven Cooking

A raised surface for oven crisping

The mesh basket elevates food above the solid pan, leaving open space for hot air to move around it.

That design is intended to encourage more even exposure than a flat surface alone, while the pan catches drippings below.

Results will depend on the food, spacing, and oven setting, so avoid crowding the basket and follow the oven’s instructions.

Useful beyond air-fry settings

The set is also described for baking, roasting, and reheating. That broader use can make a dedicated tray more worthwhile if it earns a place in the kitchen for more than one cooking task.

Its value will depend on whether the round size works for the meals and portions you actually prepare.

Check fit and care before use

At 13.12 inches round, the tray may fit many standard racks, but oven interiors and clearances vary. Measure the rack and account for any space needed to place or remove the set with oven mitts.

The coating is presented as nonstick and the parts as dishwasher-safe; follow the product’s care instructions to guide cleaning and preserve the surface.

Alternatives to Gotham Steel Crisper

Grill Baskets alternative

Cave Tools Vegetable Grill Basket
4.6/5

700+ ratings

Read Amazon Reviews

Cave Tools Vegetable Grill Basket

Choose the Gotham Steel set if you want an oven accessory with a separate drip pan. Consider the Cave Tools basket if your priority is transferring small foods to an outdoor grill in a stainless steel basket.

  • The Cave Tools basket is a rectangular stainless steel grill basket with a curved handle, described for small foods such as vegetables, fruit, shrimp, fish, and meat.
  • It is dishwasher-safe and intended for use on a grill.
  • The Gotham Steel set is designed for oven cooking and pairs a mesh basket with a solid pan for collecting grease and crumbs.

Grill Baskets alternative

Kona Smoker & Grill Basket
4.3/5

200+ ratings

Read Amazon Reviews

Kona Smoker & Grill Basket

The Gotham Steel set fits an oven-focused routine and includes a catch pan. The Kona is a more relevant option for someone who wants mesh containment for an outdoor grill or smoker, especially for smaller ingredients.

  • The Kona is a 12-by-12-inch mesh grill basket described for outdoor grilling and cold smoking.
  • Its nonstick mesh is dishwasher-safe and intended to keep small foods from falling through grill grates.
  • The Gotham Steel Crisper is a round, two-piece oven set with a coated mesh basket and solid pan underneath.

Is Gotham Steel Crisper Worth It?

The Gotham Steel Crisper Tray is worth considering if you want a reusable oven accessory that combines a raised mesh basket with a drip pan and can serve several cooking tasks.

Its design, nonstick coating, and dishwasher-safe construction are convenient features for oven-based crisping and roasting.

Buy it only after checking the 13.12-inch round footprint against your oven and considering your typical portion size.

The description offers no capacity figure, and the set depends on an oven or convection setting, so shoppers who need a standalone appliance or a defined large-batch solution should choose accordingly.

Your review at a glance

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray
4.5/5

13,000+ ratings

Read Amazon Reviews

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

A practical fit for cooks who want to crisp, bake, roast, or reheat smaller portions in a regular or convection oven.

  • Two-piece set with an elevated mesh basket and solid drip pan.
  • Round, copper-colored set measuring 13.12 inches across.
  • Aluminum core with Gotham Steel titanium and ceramic nonstick coating.
  • Designed for oven air-fry, convection, bake, roast, and reheat settings.

Written by

whatscookingblog.com Editorial Team

Editorial team

whatscookingblog.com publishes practical how-to guides and educational articles with clear steps and useful context.

Amazon customer reviews

See what buyers think

Explore customer reviews, photos and available video reviews on Amazon.

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

A practical fit for cooks who want to crisp, bake, roast, or reheat smaller portions in a regular or convection oven.

  • Two-piece set with an elevated mesh basket and solid drip pan.
  • Round, copper-colored set measuring 13.12 inches across.
Check Video Reviews on Amazon